Sunday, July 31, 2011

Graffiti Moon

Author: Cath Crowley

It is so pleasing to see this author exploring the lives of three teenagers who are deeply affected by art and poetry. This is made all the more delightful because their passion for art has emerged in a working class suburb.

Lucy has just finished Year 12, and seems to lead a relatively uncomplicated life. Her parents do have some unusual arrangements, and she does worry about them, but they are loving parents who care for her. She has become interested in glass blowing and used that medium to create her HSC major work. She does not have a boyfriend at the moment, partly due to an unfortunate incident where a boy asked her out and when he touched her bottom she lashed out and broke his nose. Lucy also has developed a passion for a local graffiti artist called “Shadow”. Unfortunately, Lucy knows him only by his evocative and soulful works, and has never actually met him. She is sure if she can only catch up with him (and his friend “Poet” ) she will have found her soul mate.

It is hardly a surprise that this plan of action goes drastically wrong, and the author tells the story by swapping between two first person narrators, Lucy, and a boy who agrees to help her find Shadow. On the way we meet their friends (and enemies). Interestingly the events actually take place over a single night.

This is not an overly subtle book. To create a dramatic situation in ordinary suburbia there is a sub-plot involving a minor gangster like figure who I did not find entirely convincing. Don’t imagine, by the way, that the book cruises along on some ethereal level discussing high art. Lucy’s friends are mostly interested in partying, relationships and drinking. There is a smattering of swearing, and quite a lot of discussion about “doing it” though no actual sex scenes.

Recommended for Senior School and above, though do be mindful of the swearing and adult themes.

Andrew Lack
Head of the Odell Learning Resources Centre

Thursday, July 14, 2011

I Am Number Four

Author: Pittacus Lore

I approached this teen novel with anticipation... "Now a major Motion Picture" proclaims the cover. Unfortunately I found myself getting rather terse with the author. There is a disconcerting unevenness and other faults.

The opening half of the book sets the scene... young John and his carer are one of only nine pairs of survivors of a planet destroyed by the hateful Mogadorians. Each pair consists of a younger person who will gradually develop special powers, and a mentor. They are hiding on Earth, but the Mogadorians are on the hunt, which means John has to shift towns constantly.

The first half is about John's arrival at a new town, a new school, and a new raft of emotions as he falls passionately in love with the prettiest girl in the school. The second part of the book reads like the script for the main action scene of a movie. It is breathlessly intense with constant cliff-edge moments.

The book overall has some interesting concepts, but before I got to the end I found I was struggling with annoyance at the writer, who seems to have watched too many TV shows to find out how to "do action". The classic trope is there: John is about to be blown away by a Mogadarian with a gun... hears a shot, looks up to see that his friend has arrived and shot the assailant.

The author can't seem to decide whether he is writing sci-fi or fantasy. There is some semi science explanations, but at other times the ideas especially of the Mogidarian powers (to do with "pulling the life force out of nearby trees") seems much more to do with magic.

There is swearing but it stays in the "minor" category. The book does espouse commendable themes of loyalty and friendship, but also has a good deal of detailed violence. The book is set up for lots of sequels. Disconcertingly key information emerges only when the plot requires it, rather than having been set up through the first half of the story. Suitable for Year Nine and above.

Andrew Lack